Deliberate disinvestment practices in New York City (NYC) have contributed to persistent disparities in health and socioeconomic status across the city. The Primary Care Development Corporation (PCDC) has released new findings that examine the lasting effects of redlining in NYC.
In 1938, the Homeowner’s Loan Corporation created so called “residential security maps” to guide entities toward practicing “responsible lending.” Neighborhoods deemed “hazardous” for lending were outlined in red—a process we know today as redlining. These maps were used as the basis to systematically deny mortgages and services to residents of redlined neighborhoods, regardless of individual creditworthiness. Predominately Black, urban neighborhoods were redlined in NYC. Despite being banned in the Fair Housing Act of 1968, decades of disinvestment have contributed to long-lasting effects for residents of formerly redlined communities.
The Issue Brief finds that:
- Formerly redlined areas have a poverty rate of 3.6 times that of A-rated census tracts.
- The proportion of Black residents in redlined areas is 9.1 time higher than that of A-rated census tracts.
- 17.8% of adults in formerly redlined areas are uninsured, compared to 6.4% in A-rated census tracts.
- 26.6% of adults in formerly lined areas are obese, compared to 16.2% in A-rated census tracts.
“This neighborhood-level discrimination practice, largely based on race, is a form of structural racism. It reinforced discriminatory distribution of resources and services and has undoubtedly contributed to poor health outcomes in Black communities,” says Angela Allard, the study’s primary author.
“Investing in access to high-quality primary care directly in these communities can begin to address accumulated inequalities and improve both the health of residents and their economic opportunities.” Says Allard.
PCDC points to increasing primary care investment in historically redlined areas, conducting data-driven assessments to identify high need populations, and using these data to strategically place healthcare resources and government programs as recommendations to strategically target disinvested communities.
Points on Care: Today’s Health Inequities in New York City Driven by Historic Redlining Practices
Download the latest Points on Care issue.